| YEAR | POSITION | NAME | UNIVERSITY |
| 2008 | RHP | Dustin Fulks | Western Oregon University |
| RHP | Michael Gleason | Chico State University | |
| MINF | Patrick Ross | Brescia University | |
| C | Roy Garcia | University of the Cumberlands, KY | |
| RHP | Steven Leeper | Chico State University | |
| OF | Spencer Tate | Cal State San Bernardino | |
| 2007 | 1B | Curtis Eubanks | York College |
| INF | Shea Davis | Cal State Monterey | |
| RHP | Derrick Miramontes | University of Illinois Chicago | |
| OF | Michael Maehl | San Jose State University | |
| 3B | Lars Ronten | South Dakota State University | |
| LHP | Aaron Grinstain | Abilene Christian University | |
| RHP | Anthony Welz | Cal State San Bernardino | |
| OF | Chris Cooper | Azusa Pacific University | |
| OF | Brent Etchepare | Chico State University | |
| OF | Nick Borowicz | Brescia University | |
| 2006 | INF | Dylan Connolly | York College |
| OF | Drew Churchward | Wayne State University | |
| LHP | Matt Davis | Abilene Christian University | |
| RHP | Andrew Delappe | Cal State Monterey | |
| 3B | Jared Votaw | Abilene Christian University | |
| C | Beau Jacop | York College | |
| C | Casey Mathews | Chico State University | |
| 2005 | OF | Mario Lewis | UC Santa Barbara |
| RHP | Alberto Rolon | Sonoma State University | |
| RHP | Ben Staveley | Brescia University | |
| INF | Josh Tavelli | UC Irvine | |
| C | Matt Kavanaugh | San Francisco State | |
| LHP | Tyler Harvey | Cal State Monterey Bay | |
| C | Jacinto Rivera | Cal State Los Angeles | |
| OF | Paolo Delosa-Tham | San Francisco State | |
| OF | Jeremy Vorheis | York College | |
| LHP | Marcus Walberg | York College | |
| 2004 | C | Mike Enyart | New Mexico Highlands |
| RHP | Glen Wood | Sonoma State University | |
| LHP | Josh Kucek | Stanislaus State University | |
| RHP | Warren Larson | Kentucky Wesleyan |