All Conference
This list only contains GVC All-Conference selections from 2002 to the present. There are no records available for previous seasons. Note: The GVC started keeping 2nd team in 2004
| First Team All-Conference | Second Team All-Conference | |||
| JD Doran | 2013 | Ryan Brown | 2012, 2013 | |
| Scott Avery | 2012 | Seth Davis | 2012 | |
| Tyler Molder | 2012 | Kyle LaClaire | 2012 | |
| Ryan Zirkle | 2012 | Hunter Graves | 2012 | |
| David Henderson | 2011 | Scott Avery | 2011 | |
| Will Enos | 2011 | Alec Abend | 2011 | |
| Tanner McIntyre | 2011 | Nick Flory | 2011 | |
| Greg Ruggles | 2010, 2011 | Taylor Johnson | 2010, 2011 | |
| Brandon Evans | 2010 | Logan Alaways | 2009, 2010 | |
| Alec Abend | 2010 | Clint Davis | 2010 | |
| Tommy Strickland | 2009 | Steven Johnson | 2010 | |
| Adam Brubaker | 2009 | Cody Brown | 2009 | |
| Jeff Machen | 2009 | Jeff Machen | 2008 | |
| Jake Gill | 2009 | Jake Gill | 2008 | |
| Michael Gleason | 2008 | Jeremy Kautz | 2008 | |
| Dustin Fulks | 2008 | Chris Cooper | 2007 | |
| Roy Garcia | 2008 | Brent Etchepare | 2007 | |
| Michael Maehl | 2007 | Lars Ronten | 2007 | |
| Taylor Clements | 2007 | Curtis Eubanks | 2007 | |
| Derrick Miramontes | 2006, 2007 | Shea Davis | 2006 | |
| Chris Cooper | 2006 | Michael Maehl | 2006 | |
| Curtis Eubanks | 2006 | Beau Jacop | 2006 | |
| Anthony Welz | 2006 | Jose Garcia | 2005 | |
| Matt Davis | 2006 | Mark Donion | 2005 | |
| Jared Votaw | 2006 | Matt Kavanaugh | 2005 | |
| Alberto Rolon | 2005 | Jared Votaw | 2005 | |
| Mario Lewis | 2005 | Mario Lewis | 2004 | |
| Josh Tavelli | 2005 | Glen Wood | 2004 | |
| Mickey Coughlin | 2003 | Scott Nielson | 2004 | |
| P.J. Gordon | 2003 | |||
| Jay Arceo | 2002 | |||
| A.J. Ghiorso | 2002 | |||
| Chad Elmy | 2002 | |||
| All-Americans | Conference Player of the Year | |||
| Dave Henderson | 2011 | Michael Maehl | 2007 | |
| Mario Lewis | 2005 | |||
| State Gold Glove Team | ||||
| Dave Henderson | 2011 | |||
| All-Northern California | ||||
| Tanner McIntyre | 2011 | Conference Pitcher of the Year | ||
| Alec Abend | 2010 | Derrick Miramontes | 2006 | |
| Michael Maehl | 2007 | |||
| Anthony Welz | 2006 | Conference Relief Pitcher of the Year | ||
| Derrick Miramontes | 2006 | JD Doran | 2013 | |
| Anthony Welz | 2006 | |||
